Things to Do in NYC Cost Calculator
Open the Menu

New York vs Chicago: Which to Visit

By the Things to Do in NYC editorial team ·

The Lower Manhattan skyline seen across the water, with a sailboat in front

Pick New York if you want the most sights in one trip and have four days or more, and pick Chicago for a shorter city break by the lake. New York vs Chicago is mostly a question of size, season and how many days you have. Both cities work well without a car, so the rest comes down to what you want to see.

Both cities are easy without a car, and the sections below compare them one by one.

DimensionNew YorkChicago
SightsObservation decks, harbor, many museumsLakefront, Museum Campus, Millennium Park
Getting aroundSubway runs 24 hours, $3 fare, $35 weekly capL train $2.50, passes of $5, $15 and $20
Weather and seasonWinter highs near 40°F, summer highs near 85°FWinter highs 30 to 38°F, summer 78 to 92°F
Trip lengthFour days or moreA long weekend works
CostHotel and ticket costs covered on this siteNot covered on this site

Sights: New York vs Chicago

New York has more different things to see, and Chicago has a tighter lakefront core. In New York you can choose among five observation decks, a harbor with the Statue of Liberty, large museums and neighborhoods in five boroughs. The city's tourism board points to the Field Museum, the Adler Planetarium and the Shedd Aquarium on the lakefront Museum Campus. The board also names Millennium Park as a free sight and Navy Pier as a family stop.

Architecture is the clearest overlap. The same tourism board suggests that you "hop on an architecture boat cruise to immerse yourself in Chicago's legendary skyline." New York has an equivalent, and the official NYC architecture cruise from €76 is a 2-hour yacht trip run by Classic Harbor Line. It has a live guide and one drink, and it is not suitable for children under 12. It suits readers who want the story of the buildings, and you can do the same view yourself for free on the Staten Island Ferry, and it does not suit anyone who wants to walk the streets instead. Its meeting point is on the tour card, and we do not publish one here. Chicago's own official river cruise, by comparison, is 90 minutes from $57 and leaves from the Michigan Avenue Bridge at Wacker Drive, according to the Chicago Architecture Center. Its boats hold up to 250 passengers, guests should arrive 30 minutes early, and refunds and exchanges are not permitted, while both New York cards here offer free cancellation.

Pro Tip If you want a free Chicago-style harbor view in New York, take the Staten Island Ferry from Whitehall Terminal. It costs nothing and runs all day and night.

Things to Do in NYC's count of GetYourGuide listings in October 2026 found 247 guided tours among 536 New York listings, the largest single type. Chicago's own numbers are not on this site, which only covers New York. The official sources used here do not rank the two cities for architecture, food or nightlife, so we do not either. The plain answer for food and nightlife is a draw, and the plain answer for architecture is also a tie: Chicago's board calls its skyline legendary and New York's skyline is just as famous, so choose by your days and season. Here is the nearest fact for each. For food and nightlife, Chicago's board lists deep dish, the jibarito, 50 or more past James Beard Award winners and house, jazz and blues venues, and New York's board gives no counts. For New York the nearest official figure is size: the city Health Department's restaurant grading site, ABCEats, covers about 29,000 restaurants, so food choice is huge in both cities and no source names a winner. New York's nearest official fact on nightlife is music: the Village Vanguard has played jazz at 178 Seventh Avenue South since 1935 and calls itself widely regarded as the city's oldest jazz club. The New York architecture cruise is narrated by a member of the American Institute of Architects New York, while the Chicago Architecture Center's river cruise tells how Chicago's architects shaped the city. For buildings, the Empire State Building opened in 1931 and reaches 1,250 feet at its highest occupied floor and 1,454 feet with its antenna, according to its own facts page, and the Skydeck in Chicago's Willis Tower hangs its Ledge 1,353 feet up. Both cities have tall, famous skylines, so pick by how many days you have. On landmark count, the nearest official figures are these: New York City's Landmarks Preservation agency protects more than 38,000 landmark properties, including 1,470 individual landmarks and 157 historic districts, while the City of Chicago's April 2026 landmark list shows 405 individual landmarks and 62 landmark districts. These count protected buildings, not quality, so neither number says which city has better architecture. If you want one plain answer, both skylines are famous, so choose by the boat ride: Chicago's river cruise is 90 minutes from $57, and New York's architecture cruise is 2 hours from €76.

Getting around: New York vs Chicago

Neither city needs a car. New York's subway runs 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, according to the MTA's subway guide. The base fare is $3, and you tap a contactless card or phone. There is no day pass. Instead, OMNY caps your fare at $35 in any 7-day period on the same card or phone.

In Chicago, the Chicago Transit Authority's fare chart lists an L train ride at $2.50 and a bus ride at $2.25. It also sells a 1-day pass for $5, a 3-day pass for $15 and a 7-day pass for $20. A ride from O'Hare airport costs $5 on the L, and a pass covers it. The fare page does not say which lines run all night. Check the agency's site before a late arrival. No official source we used compares how walkable the two cities are, so we make no claim about walking. The nearest fact is how the sights are laid out: Chicago's board groups the Field Museum, Adler Planetarium and Shedd Aquarium on one lakefront campus, while New York's sights sit in five boroughs and the subway links them. For a free walk-and-ride day in New York, the Staten Island Ferry is run by the city, costs nothing and runs 24 hours a day, every day. In Chicago the same Museum Campus walk costs only the transit fare to get there.

The two cities solve fares in different ways. Chicago sells passes. New York caps the total. For New York routes, ferries and airport trains, see our guide to getting around NYC.

Key Takeaway In New York the $35 weekly cap only counts rides on one card or phone, so each traveler should tap their own.

Weather and season: New York vs Chicago

Both cities have four real seasons, and Chicago's winters are colder. The board gives winter highs of about 30 to 38°F and a yearly snowfall of about 37 inches. For summer it lists 78 to 92°F.

New York's winter is a little milder. Central Park's 1991 to 2020 normals from NOAA show a January average high of 39.5°F and a July average high of 84.9°F. February is the snowiest month, with 10.1 inches. Rain is spread evenly, from 3.2 to 4.6 inches a month.

October is usually the driest month in Chicago, the board says. Its page also promotes winter visits, with holiday lights and dining. For New York month by month, read our guide to the best time to visit New York.

Trip length: how many days each needs

New York takes more days, because the sights are spread over five boroughs. Plan four days or more if you want observation decks, museums, the harbor and a few neighborhoods without rushing. Our page on how many days in NYC breaks it down by length.

Chicago can work as a long weekend, since much of what the tourism board lists sits along the lakefront and downtown. No official page gives a number of days for either city, so treat these as our advice, not a rule.

If you only have a few days in New York, start with the water. The 90-minute Statue of Liberty and skyline cruise from €30 is run by Circle Line, has a live English guide and does not include hotel pick-up. It runs on a short clock, so it fits a tight schedule.

The best city for a trip is the one you have enough days to enjoy.

4 days or more Choose New York A long weekend Chicago works well Only two days Pick the smaller city

New York is the wrong pick for a two-day visit. The sights are too spread out, and you will spend much of the trip on the subway.

Cost: what we can compare

Neither city is cheap, and this site can only price New York. Our hotel and ticket numbers cover New York alone, so we do not compare Chicago hotel prices here. The official fares above are the only costs we can set side by side. Because of that, we cannot say whether New York costs more than Chicago for a visitor. The two cruises are New York prices only: the architecture cruise from €76 gives a 2-hour yacht trip with a live guide and one drink, and the Statue of Liberty cruise from €30 gives 90 minutes of live narration past the statue and under three bridges. Food and nightlife costs are not published by the official sources we use. The nearest like-for-like price is the boat ride: Chicago's official 90-minute river cruise starts at $57, against New York's 90-minute cruise from €30 and 2-hour cruise from €76 (dollars and euros are not converted here). On hotels, the official pages use different formulas, so they cannot be set side by side: New York City adds $2.00 per room per night on rooms of $40 or more on top of its occupancy tax rate, according to the NYC Department of Finance, and the City of Chicago lists a 4.5% base hotel accommodations tax.

So, is New York more expensive than Chicago for a visitor? Transport is $15 cheaper over a week in Chicago, and for hotels and food the official pages do not settle it, so we call neither city cheaper overall. A subway ride in New York is $3, and a Chicago L ride is $2.50. A week of heavy riding costs at most $35 in New York and $20 with a 7-day pass in Chicago. For what a full New York trip costs, from hotels to tickets, see our guide to new york travel cost.

See New York's skyline from the water

Chicago is known for its architecture boats, and New York has its own versions. These two picks start at €30 for a 90-minute Statue of Liberty and skyline cruise and €76 for a 2-hour architecture cruise. Doing it yourself costs less, since the Staten Island Ferry is free and shows the skyline, but it has no guide to name what you see. A cruise gives you a live guide and a fixed time, so pay for one only if you want the names and the story of the buildings, and take the free ferry if you just want the view. The ferry has no ticket and no booking, and boats run every 15 to 20 minutes on weekday rush hours and every 30 minutes on weekends, per its official site, so it costs you no money and little planning, while the cruises cost €30 to €76 and run to a fixed departure time. For comparison, Chicago's own official architecture river cruise runs 90 minutes and starts at $57. Both cards show a rating, a review count and free cancellation. The architecture cruise leaves from Pier 62 at Chelsea Piers (West 22nd Street and the Hudson River), so plan to be at the pier before the 2-hour sailing starts, and the Statue of Liberty cruise leaves from Pier 83 at West 42nd Street; the exact meeting details come with your ticket. The architecture cruise runs 2 hours, the Statue of Liberty cruise 90 minutes, and neither operator publishes a boat capacity, though Classic Harbor Line asks groups of 17 or more to call first and Circle Line lists group rates for parties of 15 or more. Circle Line's page gives no boarding time, and Classic Harbor Line runs the 2-hour cruise only on set days that depend on the month, so check your date before you plan around it. Not included on the architecture cruise: tip (groups of 9 or more pay an automatic 10%) and food, which you can buy in advance or on board. Not included on the Statue of Liberty cruise: a stop at Liberty Island, since the boat passes the statue but does not dock there. Both suit first-timers who want a guide, and both are poor value for anyone who only wants a free look at the skyline. On your own, the free ferry runs between Whitehall Terminal in Manhattan and St. George Terminal on Staten Island, so a self-guided skyline view costs $0 against €30 to €76 for a cruise. In short, go on your own for the view, and book a tour only if you want a guide and a seat on the water. The architecture cruise does not suit children under 12, so families with small children should take the shorter cruise or the free ferry.

Prices and ratings as shown on GetYourGuide on 24 October 2026.

New York City on a budget: what a trip costs

FAQ

Is New York or Chicago better for a first trip?
New York suits a first trip if you have four days or more and want many different sights. Chicago suits a shorter visit centered on the lakefront, its museums and an architecture cruise. Neither needs a car. No official source ranks food, nightlife, walking or architecture between them. The nearest facts: Chicago's tourism board promotes deep dish, the jibarito and more than 50 past James Beard Award winners, plus house, jazz and blues venues, while New York's board gives no counts, and the city Health Department's ABCEats site covers about 29,000 New York restaurants. For buildings, the Empire State Building's highest occupied floor is 1,250 feet up, and Chicago's Skydeck Ledge hangs 1,353 feet up. A New York cruise beats going alone only if you want a live guide, since the Staten Island Ferry gives a free skyline view. On architecture, the New York cruise is narrated by a member of the American Institute of Architects New York, and the Chicago Architecture Center's river cruise is 90 minutes from $57. On landmark counts, New York City protects 1,470 individual landmarks and 157 historic districts, and Chicago's April 2026 list shows 405 individual landmarks and 62 districts, but a count of protected buildings does not say which city has better architecture. If you want one plain answer, both skylines are famous, so choose by the boat ride: Chicago's river cruise is 90 minutes from $57, and New York's architecture cruise is 2 hours from €76. Plain answer on architecture: it is a tie on the record, because no official page ranks the two, so the better pick is the city you have the days for.

Do you need a car in New York or Chicago?
No. New York's subway runs 24 hours a day, every day, and Chicago has its own train and bus network with 1-day, 3-day and 7-day passes. Chicago's transit agency does not state its 24-hour service on the fare page, so check its site for late-night trains.

Which city is better for walking, New York or Chicago?
No official source ranks the two for walking, so this site makes no ranking. The nearest facts: Chicago's board groups the Field Museum, Adler Planetarium and Shedd Aquarium on one lakefront campus, so they are a short walk from each other. New York's sights sit in five boroughs, and the subway runs 24 hours a day to link them. The Staten Island Ferry is free and also runs 24 hours a day. In short, Chicago's headline sights are close together, and New York's are spread out, so a Chicago visit needs less transit between stops and a New York visit means tapping onto the subway or ferry most days to link them. You walk a lot in both cities, so the real difference is the gaps between stops. Our plain answer: Chicago is easier to cover on foot in a short stay, and in New York it works best to walk one area a day and ride between areas.

Is New York more expensive than Chicago for a visitor?
No official source compares total trip costs, so this site does not say. The nearest like-for-like prices: a $3 subway ride against a $2.50 L ride, a $35 weekly cap in New York against a $20 7-day pass in Chicago, and a Chicago river cruise from $57 against New York cruises from €30 and €76. On hotels, New York City adds $2.00 per room per night on rooms of $40 or more on top of its occupancy tax rate, and Chicago's city page lists a 4.5% base hotel tax. In plain terms, a week of getting around costs at most $35 in New York and $20 with a pass in Chicago, so Chicago is $15 cheaper for transport alone, but that is not a whole-trip answer. Plainly: Chicago costs less to get around, and no official page settles hotels or food, so the honest answer is that neither city is proven cheaper overall. Plain answer: Chicago is cheaper only for getting around, and for hotels and food no official page gives a like-for-like number.

Which city has colder winters, New York or Chicago?
Chicago's tourism board puts average winter highs at 30 to 38°F and yearly snowfall at about 37 inches. In New York, the January average high is 39.5°F, according to NOAA. Both cities get snow, so pack a warm coat for either.

How much is public transport in New York and Chicago?
A New York subway or local bus ride costs $3. A Chicago L train ride costs $2.50 and a bus ride $2.25, according to the Chicago Transit Authority's fare chart. Both cities also offer passes or caps for frequent riders. No official source says whether a whole trip costs more in New York or Chicago. The only like-for-like prices are fares and boat rides: a $3 subway ride against a $2.50 L ride, and a Chicago river cruise from $57 against New York cruises from €30 and €76.

Conclusion

New York is the bigger trip, with more sights, a subway that never closes and a harbor full of boat rides. Chicago is the smaller trip, with a lakefront, an architecture scene and a cheaper pass system. If you have four days or more and want variety, choose New York. If you have a long weekend and like a compact city, Chicago is a fine pick. Whichever you choose, plan your transport around a contactless card, because both cities cap or bundle rides. A boat ride costs about the same in both: Chicago's official 90-minute river cruise starts at $57, and the two New York cruises here start at €30 and €76. No official source says which city costs less overall, so decide by days and season.

Sources